The got a big "thank you for the music"
April 07, 2020

Judge dismisses vault fire lawsuit against Universal

Judge John A. Kronstadt dismissed the class action lawsuit several artists filed against Universal Music Group because of the big Universal vault fire from 2008 that damaged at least 500,000 high-quality master recordings, Rolling Stone reports. Judge Kronstadt’s decision came after four of the five plaintiffs - Hole, Soundgarden, Steve Earle, and the Tupac Shakur estate - ended up dropping out of the suit. The case rested entirely on the remaining plaintiff: Tom Petty’s ex-wife Jane. Judge Kronstadt finally “dismissed the argument that UMG was obligated to pay Petty a portion of the recovery settlement, which the plaintiff unsuccessfully tried to characterize as a ‘license’ that ought to pay out royalties”. The judge also rejected a bailment argument that Universal failed to care for a valuable in its possession because Universal - and not Petty - actually owned the master tapes. The negligence portion of the suit was thrown out due to Petty’s standing contract with Universal, which never legally specified that Petty would be entitled to revenue from insurance claims.

In the latest filing in musicians’ class action lawsuit against Universal concerning 2008 warehouse fire, UMG has acknowledged that master recordings of these 19 artists were damaged or destroyed in the blaze: Sonic Youth, Nirvana, Elton John, Beck, Soundgarden, Sheryl Crow, R.E.M., Bryan Adams, …And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead, David Baerwald, Jimmy Eat World, Les Paul, Peter Frampton, Michael McDonald, Slayer, Suzanne Vega, Surfaris, White Zombie, and Y&T. Universal claimed 17,000 artists were affected by the fire when they were suing for damages, these 19 are merely confirmed to have their masters damaged.

Universal Music Group is claiming neither Steve Earle nor Tom Petty nor Tupac Shakur did not lose original master recordings in a 2008 fire on the Universal Studios backlot, Variety reports. An investigation into the loss of material by Soundgarden, the only other current plaintiff, is ongoing. Hole has dropped out of the lawsuit because […]

Soundgarden, Hole and Steve Earle, as well as the estates of Tom Petty and 2Pac, have filed a class action lawsuit against Universal Music Group over a fire at Universal Studios Hollywood in 2008 that destroyed 500,000 irreplaceable master recordings. The suit accuses Universal Music of negligence when it came to preventing the fire, in […]